The Art and Business of Online Writing

Picture of Mark Donnigan

Mark Donnigan

|

January 6, 2026

When Tim and I recorded the recent episode of the Marketing Execution Podcast, we didn’t set out to create a masterclass on writing. What emerged instead was something more useful for CEOs and executive leaders: a clear pattern behind why content works for some companies.

Most advice on content feels overwhelming because it’s scattered across platforms, niches, cadence, monetization, and metrics. It’s easy to miss the core principles underneath all of it.

When I step back and look at the entire conversation, three ideas do most of the heavy lifting:

    1. Platform choice determines whether content ever has a chance to work.
    2. Your niche is discovered through publishing.
    3. Content creates leverage when it’s treated as a signal.

This blog unpacks those three principles in depth, drawing on moments from the podcast and adding the CMO-level context that executive leaders need to apply them in the real world. Each section builds on the one before it, because content strategy only works when it’s cohesive.

Key Point 1: Platform choice is the foundation

Early in the episode, Tim shared a realization that sparked the entire discussion. Leaders are often encouraged to “just start creating,” but they’re rarely told where that creation should live.

I responded with a story that still frustrates me to think about. A brilliant early-stage SaaS founder spent six months writing thoughtful long-form essays on his own website. The writing was strong. The thinking was sharp. The results were nonexistent.

As I said on the podcast, publishing on your own site at the start is like opening a store in the middle of the desert. You may have something valuable, but there’s no built-in foot traffic to validate it.

From a CMO’s perspective, this isn’t about discouraging ownership. It’s about sequencing.

Platforms like LinkedIn already aggregate the audience most B2B companies want to reach. More importantly, they provide immediate feedback loops. Views, comments, saves, and engagement patterns act as early indicators of resonance.

When executives skip this step and publish exclusively on owned channels too early, they remove the most critical advantage content provides in the early stages: the ability to learn quickly.

And that insight leads directly into the second principle.

If the platform gives you feedback, the real question becomes what you’re supposed to learn from it.

Key Point 2: Your niche is discovered through data

One of the most counterintuitive moments in the conversation came when we discussed “writing to discover your niche.” Tim called it out immediately because it runs against almost every piece of conventional advice. Leaders are told to define their niche first, then create content to support it.

In practice, that approach fails more often than it succeeds. As I explained in the episode, most leaders choose a niche based on what they think should work. They commit months of effort, only to realize later that the market doesn’t care, or that the audience engaging isn’t the audience they need.

The smarter approach reverses the order.

Start with three or four topics you genuinely care about and have experience in. Publish consistently. Rotate through them. Then let the data tell you where traction actually exists.

At one point, I said, “You’re letting the market tell you what your niche should be.” That’s not a catchy phrase. It’s a strategic safeguard.

From a CMO lens, a niche isn’t just a topic. It’s the intersection of:

  • the problem you talk about
  • the specific audience engaging with it
  • the way you communicate and frame ideas

That intersection only becomes visible through repetition and measurement.

Executives often worry that narrowing focus will limit opportunity. In content, specificity does the opposite. It creates memorability. It signals relevance. It attracts the right people faster.

Once that specificity starts to form, a new challenge appears.

How do you turn engagement into something durable without eroding trust?

Key Point 3: Content works when it creates a signal

The third principle ties everything together and addresses the concern most executive leaders raise: “This all sounds great, but how does it translate to revenue?”

The answer is not through aggressive calls to action.

I shared an example of a founder who ended every post with a hard sell. 

  • Newsletter links
  • Course promotions
  • Website pushes

Engagement collapsed because the audience felt like they were being sold to, not helped. The alternative approach is quieter and far more effective. Content should first function as a signal.

As I explained when we discussed 90-day timelines, content isn’t about becoming visible overnight. It’s about learning what problems resonate, what language people use, and who is paying attention.

Every comment is feedback. Every share is insight. Even modest engagement becomes a form of market intelligence.

When the right people engage, content naturally turns into a trust-building mechanism. Conversations don’t start cold. They start warm, grounded in shared context.

This is why I said in the episode that content becomes “a prospecting tool that doesn’t feel like prospecting.”

From an executive standpoint, this reframes content entirely. It’s no longer a marketing channel chasing reach. It’s a strategic asset that reduces friction across sales, positioning, and brand credibility.

And when content is treated that way, it compounds.

How These Three Principles Work Together

These ideas don’t stand alone. They reinforce each other.

The right platform creates feedback → Feedback enables niche discovery → A clear niche builds trust → Trust turns engagement into conversations.

When any one of these breaks, content stalls. When all three align, content becomes an asset competitors can’t easily copy. This is also why consistency matters so much. Trust isn’t built by one viral post. It’s built by showing up repeatedly before anyone asks for anything.

Near the end of the episode, Tim asked what I hoped listeners wouldn’t forget. My answer still applies here:

“Your content is not about building an audience. It’s about building trust before anyone knows they need you.”

That mindset shift is where most executive teams either commit or quietly abandon content altogether.

A Final Note on Making This Sustainable

For many leadership teams, the challenge isn’t understanding these principles. It’s operationalizing them.

  • Publishing consistently. 
  • Tracking the right signals. 
  • Refining messaging. 
  • Connecting insights back to growth objectives. 

All of that requires structure and follow-through. This is often where a Marketing Pod quietly becomes useful, not as a promotional engine, but as a way to maintain consistency, discipline, and learning velocity without distracting leaders from running the business.

If these ideas resonate, I recommend listening to the full episode on the Marketing Execution Podcast. The conversation adds nuance and real-world texture that complements what you’ve read here.

Content, done well, isn’t about writing more. It’s about thinking clearly, learning faster, and earning trust over time.

🎧 Listen to the full conversation

Let’s Talk

I can’t wait to make you my next success story. 
Please complete all fields so that we can explore together how best to help your company dominate the market and achieve its full potential.

By clicking the “Submit” button, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

DOWNLOAD NOW!

To access your free downloads, please provide the following details and hit the Submit button.

Once you have submitted the form, check your email for the download links.

[sibwp_form id=4]

By clicking the “Submit” button, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

LET'S TALK

I can’t wait to make you my next success story. Please complete all fields so that we can explore together how best to help your company dominate the market and achieve its full potential.

By clicking the “Submit” button, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.